PDA

View Full Version : Podcast Review: Rutter's Ramblings


agile
Oct 22nd, 2006, 05:24 AM
http://podcastrev.com/images/ruttersramblings01.jpg

Rutter’s Ramblings is a podcast that seeks to cater to many tastes. It is released about twice a week and runs for about half an hour. Each episode features Troy discussing his life, giving his opinion (ranting) on political and social issues, some musical interludes and pop culture news.

Troy has been producing his podcast for about a year and the thing that I admired most about his show is the honesty of it. Troy has traditionally voted Republican although he now is moving away from this position to voting for independent candidates. Although my political position is probably more liberal than Troy’s, I respect where he is coming from because he is generally able to express his opinions in a well articulated manner without talking down at his audience. In recent shows Troy has given us his thoughts on the proposed plans in the US to put ‘R’ ratings on movies with smoking in them and some of his thoughts on US Federal politics.

In other parts of the show Troy will bring a more light-hearted feel to his podcast. I was amused by Troy’s apparent fascination (obsession?) with Lindsay Lohan. In recent shows there has been a ‘Lindsay Lohan Moment’ discussed in each episode. Examples of these include Lindsay declaring her 10 year plan or the fact that Lohan wants to take time off to travel.

Troy also discusses what has been happening in his life recently. It is this section of the show that I feel is the podcast’s Achilles heal. Troy’s thoughts about his life are interesting and as an audience we are interested in what is going on in his life (and his head). The problem is that too often these thoughts come across as a stream of consciousness and at times it is like Troy is having a conversation with himself (a soliloquy).

Overall Rutter’s Ramblings is a podcast that I would give a qualified recommendation to. Troy has a very engaging personality; however in its current form the show is trying to be too many things to too many people.

Podcast Rating: 7 out of 10

Website: http://www.ruttersramblings.com/
RSS Feed: http://feeds.feedburner.com/RuttersRamblingsPodcast

WyethDigital
Oct 22nd, 2006, 08:54 AM
And he's got some awesome artwork!

Eric

kickasspodcast
Oct 22nd, 2006, 06:04 PM
you should really link to the podcasts you review- I actually think you are recontenting info from your blog, which is a bit lame, would be just as good to name the show you review, link to it, and link to your full post on your blog. Just some advice from me.

Jack

WyethDigital
Oct 22nd, 2006, 06:09 PM
you should really link to the podcasts you review- I actually think you are recontenting info from your blog, which is a bit lame, would be just as good to name the show you review, link to it, and link to your full post on your blog. Just some advice from me.

Jack
It's at the bottom of the review, Jack. He linked to the site and the RSS feed.

Eric

agile
Oct 22nd, 2006, 08:05 PM
you should really link to the podcasts you review- I actually think you are recontenting info from your blog, which is a bit lame, would be just as good to name the show you review, link to it, and link to your full post on your blog. Just some advice from me.

Jack

The main reason I put the reviews here is to get publicity for the blog. Also keep in mind that I originally posted the reviews here at the alley before I even had a blog. People who enjoyed this review may be interested in reading my other 30 reviews which are at podcastrev.com

Thanks for your advice jack. Here's some free advice back at you: I think it's pretty lame when people go out of their way to post unsolicited negative feedback without being constructive on at least some level.

Maybe you need a hobby? :wink:

Regards,
Tim

WyethDigital
Oct 22nd, 2006, 08:27 PM
Careful, Tim! Don't want to piss off the Amish!

He'll quote you to death!

quote you to death!
quote you to death!
quote you to death!
quote you to death!

;)

agile
Oct 22nd, 2006, 08:36 PM
Careful, Tim! Don't want to piss off the Amish!

He'll quote you to death!

quote you to death!
quote you to death!
quote you to death!
quote you to death!

;)

Ummm. Not sure what you mean. You have been on this message board longer than me. This guy Jack sounds like a serial pest (and I'm not talking about the infestations in his beard :wink: )

On another note is it just me or do all podfaders who post here seem to have chip on their shoulder?

WyethDigital
Oct 22nd, 2006, 08:45 PM
Ummm. Not sure what you mean. You have been on this message board longer than me. This guy Jack sounds like a serial pest (and I'm not talking about the infestations in his beard :wink: )
Sorry about the obscure reference, Tim. I've found that one of Jack's debating tactics is to quote the bejeezus out of his detractors, publish them in a lengthy manifesto and attempt to claim the moral high ground by twisting, misquoting and misrepresenting what other's say. It can be a rather angry display of passive aggression.

But that's just my opinion. I'm sure he'll have something to say about it and me (en masse) at any time now!

On another note is it just me or do all podfaders who post here seem to have chip on their shoulder?
Yeah... a lot do. Be interesting to explore that topic in another thread.

Eric

agile
Oct 22nd, 2006, 08:47 PM
I wonder why he stopped podcasting. Could have been a good outlet for him to channel his agression? :P

kickasspodcast
Oct 23rd, 2006, 11:51 PM
guys, ya can post edit forum entries all ya want, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't there. Eric, grow a life man, your predictable unfunny quips are quite tiresome.


Agile, its just feedback man, you have to post on a podcast forum to get publicity for your blog? That's pretty telling.


I'm sorry but I didn't quite podcasting at all, I don't think I owe you guys an explanation either. Remember a show called skepticality taking a 6 month break, ever heard of vox monitor. Am I suddenly required to do a show all the time to please you 2? Can't somebody have a kid and take a break? Hey- at least I am a podcaster, Agile, you just have an obscure podcast review blog that needs cross traffic from this website, and Eric, your just a fecking camera man dude. Who are you to talk?

It was just feedback, its obvious that your recontenting and its a bit lame, just because you can post edit the website link doesn't mean it was there all along, the edited subtext message system is rarely reliable on this p.o.s. phpBB forum software- anyways it is beside the point because you posted in the "Top Rated" forum and the show in question has about 30 feedburner subscribers. Way to be accurate in your listings and thanks for the typical PCA sarcasm. Have fun together. Really. You have way, way too much time on your hands if your gonna have a conversation about me. Seriously.


Jack

test: I've edited this twice

WyethDigital
Oct 24th, 2006, 03:28 AM
I think he was flattered by the attention, Tim.

Eric


PS -- congrats on the baby, Jack.

agile
Oct 24th, 2006, 03:44 AM
I think he was flattered by the attention, Tim.

Eric


PS -- congrats on the baby, Jack.

Yep congrats on the baby. My wife is due to give birth to our second in 4 weeks. Is it you first? Sure is an exciting time.

Also, just to satisfy my curiousity Jack, how did you check on this podcasts feedburner stats? I thought that info was only available to the podcaster.

Cheers,
Tim

kickasspodcast
Oct 24th, 2006, 10:11 AM
Thanks for the good wishes on the baby guys. As for subscribers, theres an active feedburner button in the right column under the picture of Adam and the PP and PCA buttons that says 27 readers.


peace out-


Jack