PDA

View Full Version : Malfunction


mental-escher
Apr 7th, 2005, 05:51 PM
Alleycats! OK, so I'm pretty newbee when it comes to podcasting, having been assimilated my the corporate Borg almost 10 years ago (our company ordained "rid thyne Macs- cranial implants of MS PC's for everyone!) Yep, I used to be Mac-addict, oh so long ago... sniff. But Gates&Co have had they way with me.

So... with that disclaimer in mind, I'd like to say that its been quite interesting to see how this "podcast-o-sphere" is evolving before my very eyes over just the last month. Upon discovering podcasting (from a recent Wired mag article) I, after a day or two of mental gas, realized that this was the beginning (or middle if you count blogs) of another internet boom. That in of itself is good and bad of course, as the first boom basically turned a anarchist medium (the old w3, where we would trade guitar music TABS and lyrics, etc.) into a morbidly over-commercialized moster (pop-ups, malware, and of course our favorite mystery meat whose name I shall not utter. Don't get me wrong, commercialization brought with it good things like Yahoo, IM, Google, as well as Amazon, Netfliz, etc. But my point was... ummm- oh yeh! My discovery of podcasting and it's amazing evolution.

So, as I am want to do, when I “discovered� podcasting and saw its potential, I immediately created my own “presence� (which was pretty easy since I am not by any means a newbee to the internet- whether it be front end or back end- programming, scripting, etc.). So, maybe in hindsight that was not so good, because I didn’t really think through what I wanted to do other than say (literally! Because that IS podcasting) “here I am!� and here is my content (original music, albeit lofi, with minimal but satirical commentary). So, I’ve made a few episodes- followed loggins and stats, and of course listened to lots of what others are doing, and have come to some conclusions.

Before first- Dave Winer, and Adam Curry, thank you guys for enabling this all to happen! From the little I know, it seems that you guys were key in bringing together the parts to create such a very cool thing that is currently called “Podcasting�.

First- This is a very closed, yet diverse community. I say closed because by definition you have to have either the luxury of being able to listen to podcasts at your computer (ie, you can afford a computer and a broad band connection), or, you have that PLUS an iPod. This brings up a question for me though- what percent of people who listen to podcasts do not own an iPod?? (And yes- I looked and could not find a ready answer on Google- good lord!).

Second- Although there seems to be no �standard� podcast show format, the most popular ones currently are either voyeuristic personal blogs (like D&D) or somewhat news related (like slashdot) and with a good dose of personality and plenty of room for asides and kidding around (like VGN). This leads me in two potentially opposing directions- the inborn desire to be “popular�, and the more personally fulfilling desire to just be ones self and at the same time “contribute� to the enjoyment of like minded people. I’m still figuring it all out. And I’m speaking from a purely non-profit point of view- the commercialization of podcasting is a whole nother rant (with the caveat that commercialization of the w3 had some very positive impacts on society, at least that fraction that can afford to and has the inclination to be “connected�).

Lastly (for now)- I think I finally see that podcasting is most engaging when there is a combination of blogging (or essay-ing), audio content (music, effects, ambience, sound-scaping, etc.) and above all- freedom to do whatever floats ones boat, and in the process make some new contacts with likeminded folks. I can really understand why Howard Stern decided to go beyond the reach of the FCC by hooking up with satillite radio. How long will podcasting be "safe" from the FCC??

Well, sorry to rant on so long... Eeeek – my first real blog :p

cb

PaulCasting
Apr 8th, 2005, 12:54 AM
Nice rant...

As for how long Podcasting will be safe from the FCC... Have you seen some of the websites out there lately? Yikes! I don't think ANYTHING is banned. This is no different...

As for commercialization, I agree with you. It's going to have a fair amount of positive influence on Podcasting. The same crud we wade through on the net, we're going to have to wade through in our podcasts.

I'm just waiting for the 'get-rich-quick' crowds to start podcasting their promise of instant riches. This is going to bring a HUGE influx of people trying to figure out how to make a buck doing it (not bad in itself as long as everything is on the up-and-up).

Porncasting. I know it's a free country, but when my daughter does a search on Google for "girls school clothing" and get's hit with that crap, or when half of the emails in their Hotmail account have VERY graphic images, it's gone a little too far. I'm afraid podcasting is going to go the same way. Afraid? Maybe I should say, I'm SURE it's going to go that way. It's just a matter of when.

Just wait until the day comes they figure out how to hijack iPodder and force themselves onto your computer.

I think there's going to be a BIG opportunity for someone to sort out the Podcasts and review them for what catagory they go into.

Well, I'm sounding pretty gloom and doom here. I guess I should just enjoy it while I can.

Paul

pdadave
Apr 8th, 2005, 02:12 AM
Nice post, good read.

I can really understand why Howard Stern decided to go beyond the reach of the FCC by hooking up with satillite radio. How long will podcasting be "safe" from the FCC??

There was a lot that went into Howard Stern...but most of it came from Janet Jackson and only hit Stern because he is high profile and the Super Bowl was a high profile event. But that whole deal is a whole other story. Plus Stern is getting like three stations...not just a show.

As for how long podcasting will be safe? Right now satillite radio isn't touched by the FCC so even if it went there it would be ok. The FCC won't be able to do anything against internet broadcasts. If they were going to do anything it would probably be higher on their checklist to hit streaming stations.

yaz
Apr 8th, 2005, 03:04 AM
that post was a rant? geez, ill just wait for the cliff notes to come out on it, i don't have to patience to read that much in one sitting...he must be pissed about something...

percent20
Apr 8th, 2005, 10:59 AM
hmm.. I can't beleive that was a rant it seemed like a statement to me.

yaz
Apr 8th, 2005, 12:46 PM
if anyone can sum it up in 25 words or less, it'd be appreciated...

PaulCasting
Apr 8th, 2005, 02:33 PM
Here's I'll sum it up (probably not the best person to do so, considering the length of my reply):

Noob podcaster using Windows instead of a mac

Thinks podcasting is going to be big and more commercialized (good and bad).

he's a geek so it was easy for him to create a podcast about nothing.

Kissing Dave and Adams butt.

Poor people don't have iPods and some don't have broadband, so the market is limited.

Can't decide whether he wants to do an interesting podcast or another lame one like Dawn and Drew.

Podcasting is free from FCC regulations.. but for how long?

That's it....

Craig
Apr 8th, 2005, 02:51 PM
That was more than 25 words. How about:

"Podcasting, wow! Thanks Adam and Dave! Who's listening? Do I want to be popular or do I want to be me? I'll be me."

Craig

yaz
Apr 8th, 2005, 03:04 PM
thanks alot guys...i think all that he's said has been said a million times on this site...